Risk Wire: Corporate Debt to GDP – Should We Worry?

In recent years there have been increasing concerns over corporate debt build-up in the US and Europe. Debt levels are considered high IF they cannot be sustained – in our assessment, a difficult claim to make for US and European companies.

 

The marked increase in the stock (volume) of corporate debt both in developed and emerging markets, particularly in comparison to the GDP levels, has triggered a concern over the balance sheets of the corporate sector and the build-up of financial risks.
Indeed, the total debt dynamic for instance in the US appears unsustainable, reaching ~73% of GDP in 2019 (Figure 1). Debt to GDP in European countries has reached 130-140% of GDP, up 10-25 percentage points compared to the 2008 levels.

However, there is a common misconception that higher debt levels automatically translate into riskier business or worse balance sheet. If this were the case, there would be a direct relationship between the level of debt adjusted for the economy (GDP) and the interest rate, which reflects the riskiness of debt…

Run Economic and Geo-political Scenarios

Explore how Agent-Based Models (ABMs) can be used to run stress tests and scenario analyses.

Risk Wire: Climate Change – The Cost of Transition

We have integrated the available industry-level climate change transition research from multiple sources and included climate change transition as the fourth long-lasting trend in Mira ABM*, along with automation, ageing population and globalisation/trade conflicts.

 

The transition of our economy in response to the climate change has begun in the earnest and is likely to continue in the years to come. The ultimate physical impact of climate change is arguably still uncertain, not least because it depends on the speed and extent of the policy reaction of major countries. Yet, there are energy transition facts that are already having significant impact on global supply chains, economic development and consequently, on asset pricing. Most importantly, these transition facts will continue to have impact on asset pricing in the foreseeable future, which qualifies climate change as the fourth long-lasting trend included in Mira ABM – our strategic asset management platform, along with ageing population, automation, and globalisation/trade conflicts.

 
Attempts to account for climate change in asset pricing so far have been focused on top-down macroeconomic analysis. Such analysis often misses the complexity of the underlying supply chain shifts. At the same time, there are detailed industry-specific studies covering climate change; however, they are fragmented and focused on individual industries. In this report, LINKS have tried to combine the body of knowledge on climate change from multiple industries into a single supply chain picture and draw conclusions with respect to asset prices.

 

Run Economic and Geo-political Scenarios

Explore how Agent-Based Models (ABMs) can be used to run stress tests and scenario analyses.

Risk Wire: China – The Threat of Unchecked Leverage

In the six years since LINKS first covered risks of excessive leverage in the Chinese economy, both understanding of and dealing with leverage has been a key focus for the government of China. Despite this focus and even though the debt is domestically funded, the results of deleveraging are less than encouraging. Sustainability of this debt is further away, which has major consequences for global investment portfolios.
In 2012 LINKS Analytics wrote about the looming debt crisis in China (Global Systemic Risks, 2012). At that time, we estimated the size of the local government finance vehicle (LGFV) debt at $4.2 trillion, or nearly double the size of Moody’s estimate. The conclusion was that the size of this debt was too large to grow out of (as China had previously done).
Through the following six years China’s policy makers continued to balance the demands of managing the mounting debt on one hand and delivering the economic growth on the other. China’s economy did not implode under the debt burden but judging by the now widespread recognition of the problem, the debt issue did not go away.
We believe It is now time to revisit the issue of systemic risks posed by China’s economy, focusing specifically on the following questions:

  1. Is China still inefficient and is debt still accumulating?
  2. If so, is it more or less sustainable in 2019 compared to 2012?
  3. What are, if any, signs of imminent distress?
  4. What would be the impact on balanced portfolios in case of an economic collapse?

To answer the last question, we use scenarios in LINKS Mira Agent-Based Model (ABM), which enables assessment of system-wide impact of scenarios on investment portfolios.

Run Economic and Geo-political Scenarios

Explore how Agent-Based Models (ABMs) can be used to run stress tests and scenario analyses.

Risk Wire: Do Inflationary Concerns Warrant Hedging?

Some sources of inflationary risk are more benign than others. Given the structural headwinds that the global economy faces, a broad inflation hedging programme can be expensive and unnecessary. On the other hand, the likelihood of unexpected inflation driven by regulation or supply shocks is increasing. This points to a more targeted approach when managing inflation risk.
Continuously low interest rates in the face of very low unemployment rate justifiably raise inflationary concerns. Protecting institutional portfolios against inflation does not come cheap – sensible hedge against inflation comes with increasing volatility and adds to the risk of the portfolio. It is therefore worthwhile to consider whether at least in the typical “core” scenarios of pension funds, inflationary concerns are truly justified.
The persistent low-trending levels of inflation in the past two decades are likely to be the effect of the emergence of global value chains and automation. Although there is significant political push-back against globalisation that can in theory reverse its effect on inflation, i.e. cause domestic price increases, our estimates suggest that the disinflationary effects of automation and ageing population in the coming years more than make up for the difference. In fact, if anything, the combined effect of long-term structural trends point at ~ 90 bp lower demand-driven inflation going forward. An active inflation hedging program for demand-driven inflation is therefore likely to cost more than its potential benefit.

Run Economic and Geo-political Scenarios

Explore how Agent-Based Models (ABMs) can be used to run stress tests and scenario analyses.

Oil Fatigue: Never Strong Again?

The US economy, in its permanent quest to achieve energy independence, has driven itself into yet another unsustainable state. Counterintuitively, allocating to commodity and oil exporting emerging market equities and debt might just prove to be the winning strategy going forward.
So much of the present investment policy status quo depends on the commodity prices that the implicit assumptions about the current doldrums in the commodity markets continuing for longer period affects long-term asset allocation. Among other things, this assumption has an impact on equity allocation to the emerging markets, high-yield credit allocation in the US, alternatives, infrastructure – you name it, it all depends on what one believes about the commodities, and particularly the oil price.
In our 2011 Global Systemic Risks review we wrote: “…despite higher production (non-OPEC countries) spare capacity in OPEC countries and falling consumption by non-OECD countries the oil price continues to go up. We explain this by the significant impact of the long positions in oil by financial institutions. A further slowdown in the global economy and oil demand will shift the long interest into short interest and cause large price swings. This will dampen the appetite of institutional investors and cause a period of very low oil prices ($20-40 per barrel).”.At the time of course the $ 20-40 range was career-threateningly far from the current price and the anchoring level. That range was eventually breached, partly due to the reasons we expected, and partly due to things that at the time were hard to predict. The drastic change in the oil price level shifted a number of dependencies in the global economy. In this issue of the Risk Wire we assess the supply chain impact of the current low oil prices on the US economy and propose reasons for the unsustainable low-price regime.
Download the paper